Comparisons between Flexpipe and Creform - Why Flexpipe is the best Pipe and Joint Product for your Modular System
Our analyses of competitors’ products and our customer feedback indicate that for most applications, Flexpipe offers products and services superior to those of the competition. We carried out a comparative study of Flexpipe’s products and services and the other pipe and joint companies to identify each one’s strengths and weaknesses. You will also find price comparison tables for three structures. The purpose of this analysis is to facilitate decision-making when choosing between the different suppliers of similar modular systems. In the end, the choice is simple!
|Purchasing process - Purchase online||★★★★★||Not applicable|
Flexpipe offers the Flexpipe Creator design tool, an extension of SketchUp. Designing structures is quick and easy.
Returns in less than three months under the following conditions:
The deadline is shorter, but the policy is practical if you order too much material for a project.
Returns in less than six months under the following conditions:
The deadline is twice as long but more restrictive with credit.
|Terms of sale||★★★||★★★★|
Comparable quality products at unbeatable prices
Here are a few examples of Flexpipe products
Flexpipe offers a wide variety of 28mm pipes in several color choices. You will have the choice between cold rolled steel pipes or stainless steel pipes, some of which are designed to minimize the possibility of electrostatic discharge (ESD).
Flexpipe/Creform Comparison tables of 3 different projects
Price Comparison Flexpipe/Creform - 10 Most Popular Items
|Flexpipe Part Number||Flexpipe Price||Number Creform Part Number||Creform Price||Savings with Flexpipe|
Flexpipe vs. Creform comparison table
Technical product comparisons
Here you will find technical comparisons between Flexpipe and Creform products. The outside diameter (28 mm) of the pipes is the same for Flexpipe and Creform, so the vast majority of parts, including joints, work on both Flexpipe and Creform pipes.
Creform sells primarily 4’ lengths, and some colors are also available in 8’ lengths. Flexpipe sells primarily 8’ lengths, and some colors are available in 4’ lengths. There are advantages and disadvantages to each of these lengths. One hand, the 8’ costs less to ship, is easier to handle, safer, easier to store as there is no need for a wooden container in which to store it, but there will be waste to anticipate when cutting lengths for certain projects. The article, entitled Why to buy 8-foot pipes, deals with this issue and sums up the difference between the two.
Problematic cases encountered
ABS glued to steel pipe
This problem encountered with Creform pipes has an advantage and a disadvantage. Since it is glued, it is more durable over time, but it cannot be recycled. This problem seems to be a significant issue for Toyota plants in Japan, which are using this type of pipe.
Flexpipe’s manufacturing method makes it possible to remove the plastic sheath from the pipe. This can pose a problem if the pipe is stuck by a sharp object, which is a fairly rare situation, but you still have to be vigilant, especially with transport carts. On the flip side, the pipe is easily recycled because you can separate the plastic from the steel at the recycler.
- 0.7 mm steel thickness with Creform
- 1.0 mm steel thickness with Flexpipe
Flexpipe’s load capacities are a little higher. It is difficult to say how much higher, because, if we consider 39” (1000 mm), Creform’s 0.7 mm pipe has a capacity of 128 lbs, and Flexpipe’s 1.0 mm pipe has a 240-lb capacity. We do not have sufficient data to compare the results.
[caption id="attachment_21200" align="alignnone" width="814"] Flexpipe loading capacity difference between pipe types[/caption]
[caption id="attachment_21215" align="alignnone" width="814"] Flexpipe single point loading capacity chart[/caption]
Since the thickness of the steel is different between Flexpipe and Creform, the internal diameter differs by 0.6mm between the two brands. Certain parts designed to fit into the pipe, such as casters, caps, or other accessories, should be checked. Several of them work, but others do not.
[caption id="attachment_21369" align="alignnone" width="1085"] Thickness comparison[/caption]
Tube color comparison
Some colors may vary, and not all colors are offered in both companies. Here is a color comparison table to help you see the differences.
Flexpipe joints have more grip inside, and so I would say that a pull and push test would have better results. This is particularly attractive in the HJ-2 corner joint, which often supports shelving.
Creform joints are 9.7% heavier and seem stiffer than Flexpipe’s. Even if their thickness is identical, that is 2.5mm. The steel used by Creform seems of better quality, which could be more durable if we have to frequently disassemble structures to assemble new ones.
|Part number||Creform weight (lbs)||Flexpipe weight (lbs)||Difference|
The coating on the parts seems very similar, and the quality of the two suppliers is excellent. At Flexpipe, we use a black electro-galvanized coating (e-coated), which is difficult to scratch. Information is more limited on the Creform website, but our tests provide similar results for black joints. Both companies display the part numbers on the joints, which is a handy little detail when it comes to asking a new employee to assemble a structure with a plan showing the part numbers!
At Flexpipe, we have added safety holes on some popular joints like the HJ-1 and HJ-2.
[caption id="attachment_21230" align="aligncenter" width="407"] At Flexpipe, we have added safety holes on some popular joints like the HJ-1 and HJ-2.[/caption]
"In the safety screw, one of my colleagues saw a lack of quality assurance of the product. In reality, I used these holes quite often and would have liked to have had them when I assembled Creform. The holes are used, among other things, to secure the corners which are often exposed to being struck by carts. They also serve as cantilever structures and, more ironically, they serve to "secure" the Department of Environment, Health and Safety (EHS). "
- Kaizen Leader at a kitchen cabinet maker in Wisconsin.
Flexpipe joints have two guidelines on their sides to check if the pipe is properly inserted. Like a Poka-Yoke, this visual indicator helps less-accustomed assemblers ensure that their assembly is safe and prevents using pipe that is cut too short. A rack’s capacity is defined by its design and compliant assembly.
[caption id="attachment_21233" align="aligncenter" width="407"] Flexpipe joints have two guidelines on their sides to check if the pipe is properly inserted.[/caption]
Always keep in mind that the Flexpipe range of joints (HJ) works well on a Creform pipe and that the reverse is also true. This compatibility is possible thanks to the outside diameter.
In the field, it is quite common for a cart or assembly line to be dismantled and the joints to be stored in containers until the next structure is assembled. In order to avoid problems during a change of supplier, it is good to know that joints are compatible with modular component manufacturers.
The two companies’ systems are primarily metric, so this helps with compatibility. For example, the bolts and nuts are, in both cases, identical, i.e., M-6, and both require the same tools. In addition, the set of keys used for most assemblies is the same. This is the case, for example, with HJ-1, HJ-6, and HJ-7.
The length and alignment of the holes for the M-6 are much the same. For example, with the HJ-4, the holes may not be perfectly aligned, but the bolt and nut can still be connected.
It should be understood that a joint assembly involves at least two parts: the bolt and the nut. This is the case for the HJ-1 = H-1 + H-1 + bolt + nut. We will, therefore, compare the H parts, which are the most common.
|Flexpipe part number||Creform part number||Compatibility|
For the complete list, download the comparison table:
[caption id="attachment_21242" align="aligncenter" width="407"] To form the Creform H-12, you must combine the H-12 and Flexpipe’s AP-HINGE to make the HJ-12 set (Creform calls it the Creform HJ-10).[/caption]
[caption id="attachment_21245" align="aligncenter" width="407"] To form the Creform H-12, you must combine the H-12 and Flexpipe’s AP-HINGE to make the HJ-12 set (Creform calls it the Creform HJ-10).[/caption]
The combination of a Flexpipe H-1 with a Creform H-1 works very well to form an HJ-1.
[caption id="attachment_21251" align="aligncenter" width="407"] The Flexpipe H-2 goes very well with the Creform H-4. The two forms an HJ-3 set.[/caption]
Creform has more models, including 2”, 3” and 4” diameter casters.
Flexpipe offers 3” and 4” diameter casters.
Creform’s casters have a rubber or urethane tread.
Flexpipe’s casters have a rubber tread only.
[caption id="attachment_21254" align="aligncenter" width="814"] Flexpipe offers 3” and 4” diameter casters.[/caption]
If we compare the most common casters, for example, the 3” swivel caster with brake and rubber sole (W-3ESB vs. ESW-75SR), the product quality is very similar. The bearing is very good in both cases and the tread quality as well. The Creform caster seems to take a little more load, but Flexpipe’s locking foot brake is easier to use.
Both brands use expansion rubber attached to the caster.
Since the internal diameter of the pipes differs, it is important to know the following details:
The Creform caster will work in the Flexpipe pipe, but you will need to widen the stem further.
The Flexpipe caster will not fit into the Creform pipe because the stem rubber is too wide by about 0.6 to 0.8 mm. You can sand it in order to make it fit.
You can replace a caster on an existing cart, and thus use a mix of Creform and Flexpipe casters on the same structure, but be aware that the wheel colors differ and that the heights vary from ⅛ “, 3/16” and ½,” depending on the wheel models.
Flexpipe vs. Creform comparison table
Creform has more models, including 5”, 6” and 8” diameter casters.
Flexpipe has 4” and 6” casters.
Creform’s casters have a rubber or polyurethane tread. Flexpipe’s casters have only a rubber tread.
Creform does not offer the smaller 4” mounting plate, which is available through Flexpipe.
Flexpipe and Creform have the same 6” mounting plate.
The only caster compatible between the two brands is the 6” model (150 mm at Creform).
Both brands use similar mounting plates, with the same M-8 bolt, but Creform uses 2x fewer bolts per plate.
Creform has a few series of roller tracks. The series has aluminum or galvanized casing with stainless steel axles. The roller track needs to be butted with a clip to prevent wheels “free falling” from casing. Aluminum is lightweight and is less noisy when bins are rolled. If you want to have ESD, you need to purchase galvanized steel.
The first group consists of EF-2044, EF-2045,EF-2047D and EF-2047F. This group has a 40mm wide and 35 mm high aluminum casing. Because of the width, Flexpipe mounts can be used in this series, although a gentle strike with a mallet is required. Creform mounts can be used on Flexpipe roller tracks. The difference between the various options is in the diameter and type of wheel used.
|Creform code||Casing type & width, height||Wheel diameter & type||Flexpipe equivalent|
|EF-2044||Aluminum, 40 mm, 35 mm||34 mm, flat||R40-RT96|
|EF-2045||Aluminum, 40 mm, 35 mm||44 mm, flat||R40-RT96|
|EF-2047D||Aluminum,40 mm, 35 mm||44 mm, narrow||R40-RT96|
|EF-2047F||Aluminum,40 mm, 35 mm||34 mm, flanged||R40-RT96|
Creform has 4000 mm long roller tracks, except EF_2044, which is also available in 2500 mm and 3000 mm lengths.
The second group consists of PCC2-3000-H16-EBL and KKC2-3000-H16-EBL. It is an ESD galvanized steel that is 40 mm wide and 35 mm high. Mounts can be interchanged in the same order as the previous series.
|Creform code||Casing type, width, height||Flexpipe equivalent|
|PCC2-3000-H16-EBL||Galvanised, 40 mm,35 mm||R40-RT96|
|KKC2-3000-H16-EBL||Galvanised,40 mm,35 mm||R40-RT96|
Flexpipe’s choice is R40-RT96, which comes in an 8’ length and with a galvanized steel casing. Since it is also ESD, it consolidates the choice into one option. The casing is 40 mm wide and 32mm high, and will easily fit into Creform’s mounts, although they may be a bit loose.
The third group is the place (wide track roller). Again there are many options, but the same result can be obtained by having only one type. The casing is galvanized steel with a stainless axle. There are six non-ESD and 3 ESD rollers. They come mainly in 3-meter lengths.
The casing is 88.6 mm wide and 28 mm high.
The fourth group is the mini skate wheel roller tracks. These have 29.5 mm wide casing and come with ESD or none-ESD.
Flexpipe offers a single product to obtain the desired result. The casing is galvanized steel and ESD. It is 85 mm wide and 32 mm high. The roller tracks will fit into the Creform mounts but are a bit loose. The wide roller track is used when the material conveyed has a large surface area. This works well to convey cardboard or bins with an oddly-shaped bottom surface (ex. honeycomb).
Track roller mounts
The various mounts offered by both companies are secured by snapping them into the pipe. In both cases, all mounts snap into the 28mm; therefore, there is no concern for incompatibility.
Flexpipe’s mounts have a pilot-hole, if needed, to secure mounts with self-tap.
Flexpipe mounts are galvanized and ESD rated.
Creform mounts are plated, but not ESD. The only series that has conductive plated mounts is the mini skate wheel roller tracks.